An argument in a formal language shows the logical form of the natural language arguments obtained by its interpretations. To argue however is not the same as an arguement. Nor is the logical definition of 'argue' the same as what is commonly referred in public.
One can argue the case of XYZ say in law or physics, or one can argue on the street in which case bickering would be a more appropriate word. For example Alice had an arguement with Bob where she accused him of paranoia , would not be considered a debate. Here Alice argues the point that Bob has paranoia. One can argue at a debate, and an argument, but an arguement is not a debate. In most of the cases of 'arguments', one could substitute another word such as row , tiff , bickering , and various other words.
Where debate is concerned, one could use the word arguement, but not words such as row or bicker. The difference is that argument usually has a more negative connotation to it. It implies a possible quarrel, people talking over each other and impoliteness.
My wife and I had an argument last night. The neighbors called the cops, that's how loud we were. I was so ashamed. Debate , on the other hand, is usually a conversation between people expressing two sides of a certain topic in a polite and respectable manner. I found out my son was drinking more than enough at a party, so I got worried, but I sat down with him, we had a debate and I believe he understands he shouldn't repeat what he did.
He is quite intelligent, so we understood each other easily. Within the American legal system, two processes are linked inextricably: debate and argument. If you read any published opinion of any court within the U. In American jurisprudence, an argument is simply a line of reasoning judges use to arrive at a decision or ruling.
After they decide a case, the judges issue a ruling, commonly called an opinion. Since within a panel of judges the majority determines the outcome of the case, one of the majority judges writes the opinion, after which the government publishes it and the general public is free to scrutinize it.
As they formulate their arguments—again, their lines of reasoning—that culminate in their decisions, judges are required to respect past judicial decisions, constitutions federal and state , statutes, and rules and regulations, both past and present. The notion of stare decisis obviates the need to reinvent the wheel, so to speak, every time a new case arises.
Keep in mind, however, that judges are not necessarily bound to rubber stamp past decisions. After all, no two cases are identical. The cast of characters and circumstances change from case to case. Despite obvious similarities there may often be not-so-obvious dissimilarities, called distinguishing facts. Supreme Court, you detect a virtual debate that has already taken place between the deciding judges in the present case and the deciding judges from past cases.
Please note: comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment. Notify me of followup comments via e-mail.
Written by : Aaron Hutchinson. User assumes all risk of use, damage, or injury. Debate Differ. Argument vs Debate Example. One Is Part of the Other An argument is a part of a debate, which is the whole. A Difference in Formality In their common use, a debate is considered more formal than an argument. Informal Use With Examples Most people think of an argument as a yelling match or negative discussion.
The couple got into an argument about how much money to spend on their vacation. Talking about religion at Thanksgiving always leads to a family argument. My dad and I had a debate about the death penalty at dinner last week. Can this abortion debate wait for another time, not at this birthday party?
Formal Use With Examples A formal debate is a scheduled event that involves specific debate rules and enforcement of those rules. The presidential debate will be on Channel 2 tonight. Our high school team won the national debate. The Senate is having a debate about whether to pass the new bill. The argument is a non-contested but competitive rise of disputes and characterized discussions for disagreement.
It is a contest of formal discussions about a given topic. It is often held in an assembly hall where the two opposing teams are seated across from one another. The debate is always held formally as it is held as a contest with participants who are against and with the given topic.
The argument does not lead to decisions but rather leads to heated conversations and disputes about the same disagreement. A conclusion arrives at that is decided by democratic means or voting for the opinions posted from either side and the ones who had good facts supporting them. It is usually used to persuade someone and is often referred to as a persuasive course. It is also used for summarizing prose or poetry.
0コメント